Caribbean

Caribbean Luxury Travel

Caribbean luxury travel is most of what I book, and after enough of it you stop thinking in islands and start thinking in resorts and room categories. St. Lucia is not Grand Cayman. Anguilla is not Punta Cana. I'm Beverly Schulte, and I plan these trips from Sioux Falls for people all over the country who want the week to work the first time.

This guide is part of my Caribbean and Mexico luxury travel planning.

The Pitons seen from a resort terrace in St. Lucia, Caribbean luxury travel

Caribbean

Picking the island before you pick the hotel

People usually come to me with a resort name they saw somewhere. I start one step earlier. Do you want to leave the property, or do you want to not think for seven days? Are you flying with kids who melt down after four hours in the air? Is anybody in the group going to want a golf course, or a reef, or a real restaurant scene?

The drive from Hewanorra to Soufrière is short but winding, and I'll have your transfer waiting. Grand Cayman gives you a flat, easy island, good food, and Seven Mile Beach. Turks and Caicos has the water everyone wants in the photos and very little else going on, which for a lot of couples is the whole point. Anguilla is quiet and expensive. The Dominican Republic gets you the most resort for the money if you pick carefully.

Caribbean

Grand Cayman, and why the side of the island matters more than the resort

I'm a certified Cayman Islands specialist, with training that includes the islands' weddings and romance track, and I've done an industry training day with Cayman Airways and the island's resort partners. Here's what I tell clients.

Grand Cayman is an easy island. It's just over an hour's flight from Miami, the water is calm, and the food is the reason a lot of people go. The Cayman Islands have more than 200 restaurants, and Cayman Cookout brings big-name chefs to the Ritz-Carlton every January.

Where you stay changes the whole trip. Seven Mile Beach on the west coast has the restaurants and the calm water, and the trade winds have kept it clear of the sargassum that reached the south coast in 2025 and 2026. Wyndham Reef Resort is Grand Cayman's best-known all-inclusive. That's perfect if you want to snorkel off the beach and stay put. It's a long drive to dinner if you don't.

For divers this is serious country. Bob Soto opened the Caribbean's first dive operation on Grand Cayman in 1957, and there are 365 moored dive sites across the three islands. On Little Cayman, Bloody Bay Wall is the one divers plan whole trips around.

What I actually brief clients on is more practical. Leave any ammunition at home, even a spent casing on a keychain or in a piece of jewelry, because it's illegal there and it can get you arrested. And if you're adding Little Cayman, know that there's no hospital on the island.

Want the full picture before you decide? My Grand Cayman Planning Guide walks through every part of the island, the sargassum question coast by coast, and where I'd put you.

Caribbean

The room is the trip

Two rooms at the same resort can be a different vacation. At Jade Mountain in St. Lucia the whole reason to go is the open fourth wall, so a room without it is money spent on the wrong thing. At Sandals Grande St. Lucian the swim-up rooms on the lagoon side stay quiet and the ones nearer the pool bar do not. At the Ritz-Carlton on Grand Cayman I'll ask which tower before I ask anything else.

This is the part booking sites can't tell you, and it's why I ask so many questions before I quote anything.

Caribbean

Hurricane season, honestly

June through November is the season, and September is the peak of it. Rates drop for a reason. I book that window when the trip is flexible and the client understands the tradeoff, and I put insurance on it every time. If you have one week a year and it can't move, I'll steer you to January through April and tell you what it costs.

Sample itinerary

A week in St. Lucia, the way I'd build it

This is a real shape, not a brochure. Seven nights, two properties, one travel day in the middle that doesn't eat the trip.

  1. Day 1

    Arrive UVF, drive south

    Fly into Hewanorra rather than Castries so the transfer runs toward Soufrière instead of across the island. The drive from Hewanorra to Soufrière is short but winding, and I'll have your transfer waiting. Dinner at the hotel the first night, always. Nobody makes a good decision after a travel day.

  2. Days 2 to 3

    Soufrière and the Pitons

    Sulphur Springs early, before the buses. The mud bath is worth doing once and it will ruin a swimsuit. Afternoon on the water with a private captain out to Anse Cochon, which beats the group catamaran by a wide margin for what it costs.

  3. Day 4

    Nothing

    I build one of these into every week. No transfer, no reservation, no guide waiting. It's the day people tell me about later.

  4. Days 5 to 6

    Move north to Rodney Bay

    A short helicopter hop or a driver up the west coast, depending on budget and stomach. The north end gives you restaurants outside the resort, Pigeon Island, and a beach that's easier to swim off than the volcanic sand down south.

  5. Day 7

    Home

    Late checkout arranged in advance, day room if the flight is evening. Transfers timed to the actual airport, not the closer one.

Questions

Questions I get asked.

Grand Cayman or Turks and Caicos if you want easy and calm water. St. Lucia if you want scenery and don't mind the drive. I'd rather ask you three questions than guess, because the wrong island is the one mistake that's hard to fix once you're there.

In St. Lucia, Jamaica, and the Dominican Republic, often yes, because eating off property is a hassle. In Grand Cayman and Anguilla, usually no, because the restaurants are the reason to be there. I run the math both ways before I recommend one.

Late August through early October. That's also the middle of hurricane season, so I only book it with insurance and with clients who can move if a storm forms.

Yes, and I'd rather you let me. Connections out of Sioux Falls to the islands are tight, and I've seen too many people miss the last flight of the day to San Juan and spend the first night of a honeymoon in an airport hotel.

A week for two at a luxury resort runs about $5,500 to $10,000 in shoulder season, before flights. Butler suites over the holidays go well past that. Jade Mountain and the Anguilla properties run higher. I'll tell you early if what you want and what you've budgeted don't line up.

Wyndham Reef Resort is Grand Cayman's best-known all-inclusive. Little Cayman Beach Resort and Cayman Brac Beach Resort on the sister islands offer all-inclusive plans too, both built around diving. Most people staying on Grand Cayman go room-only, because the restaurants are the point.

Some seasons, yes, mostly on the south and east coasts. 2025 brought a record influx, and the south coast saw heavy accumulations in May 2026. Seven Mile Beach stayed clear because of the trade winds. I check current conditions before I recommend which side of the island to stay on.

Yes. It's one of the best food islands in the Caribbean, Seven Mile Beach has calm water for swimming, and the snorkeling is easy from shore. Diving is a bonus here, not a requirement.

Most crime that affects visitors is petty theft. The two things I make sure every client knows are the strict ammunition law and the limited medical care on Little Cayman and Cayman Brac.

Related

Where this fits.

Caribbean rolls up into a bigger pillar of my planning work. Caribbean and Mexico luxury travel has the wider view, and the journal has the notes I write between trips.

Begin

Start the conversation.

Tell me who's going and roughly when. I'll tell you honestly what Caribbean takes to do properly, and whether I'm the right person for it.

Last updated

Last updated